{
 "page": "/enhance-voicemail-audio/",
 "preparedOn": "2026-11-20",
 "test": {
  "voicemails": 36,
  "madeHow": "Each test voicemail is a clean recording sent through real phone codecs (G.711, GSM 06.10, AMR-NB, Opus) on a simulated network, then saved as MP3, M4A, AMR or 3GP. None is a real voicemail.",
  "cleanedWith": "Diffio 4.7 Pro, once per voicemail, on 2026-11-19, from the delivered phone file",
  "alsoRun": [
   "Adobe Podcast Enhance Speech (free plan, 2026-11-20)",
   "ffmpeg's afftdn noise reduction",
   "DeepFilterNet3"
  ],
  "measures": {
   "speechQualityScoreq": "SCOREQ no-reference speech quality, 1 to 5",
   "voiceSimilarityToClean": "speaker-embedding cosine similarity of the whole file against the clean recording it was made from (1 = same voice)",
   "voiceSimilarityPhoneBand": "the same similarity with both files limited to 300 to 3,400 Hz, the band a phone carries",
   "wordErrorRate": "an automatic speech recognizer's transcript of the file against the clean recording's transcript",
   "changedWords": "every word difference the recognizer flagged was read by hand against the audio: 32 flagged, 6 places (7 words) really changed"
  },
  "results36": {
   "speechQualityScoreq": {
    "phone": 2.19,
    "diffio": 4.74,
    "clean": 4.21,
    "adobe": 3.81
   },
   "wordErrorRate": {
    "phone": 0.055,
    "diffio": 0.034,
    "adobe": 0.131
   },
   "voiceSimilarityToClean": {
    "phone": 0.569,
    "diffio": 0.61,
    "adobe": 0.552,
    "diffioLowerThanPhone": 14
   },
   "voiceSimilarityPhoneBand": {
    "phone": 0.704,
    "diffio": 0.79,
    "diffioHigherThanPhone": 28
   },
   "olderMenTalking": {
    "clips": 6,
    "phone": 0.684,
    "diffio": 0.606,
    "diffioLower": 6
   },
   "changedWordsHandRead": {
    "words": 7,
    "of": 3187,
    "clips": 4
   }
  },
  "listeningCopies": "Each version is excerpted at the same start and length, with one fixed gain per file so all three play at about -20 LUFS; mono MP3 at 96 kb/s, 44.1 kHz, 20 ms fades. No other processing.",
  "noHumanListeningTest": true
 },
 "clips": [
  {
   "slug": "quiet-m4a",
   "testId": "vm32",
   "label": "made by passing a clean recording through real phone codecs (not a real voicemail)",
   "phoneChain": "phone band 300-3400 Hz at 8 kHz -> Opus 10 kbps VoIP (ffmpeg libopus, 20 ms frames)",
   "deliveredAs": "AAC 32 kbps in M4A (the format an iPhone voicemail Share / Save to Files gives)",
   "situation": "quiet room, phone held to the mouth",
   "voice": {
    "speaker": "Ty Lasky",
    "work": "Letters on Different Subjects in Natural Philosophy, Volume 1 (Letters to a German Princess), section 68 (More Particular Account of the Dispute Respecting Universal Gravitation)",
    "sourcePageUrl": "https://librivox.org/letters-on-natural-philosophy-vol1-by-leonhard-euler",
    "license": "public domain (LibriVox recording; LibriVox dedicates its recordings to the public domain)",
    "credit": "Ty Lasky, LibriVox (librivox.org)"
   },
   "noise": null,
   "license": "Public domain",
   "excerpt": {
    "startSeconds": 6.0,
    "durationSeconds": 26.9,
    "clipSeconds": 38.47
   },
   "files": {
    "phone": "quiet-m4a-phone.mp3",
    "diffio": "quiet-m4a-diffio.mp3",
    "clean": "quiet-m4a-clean.mp3"
   },
   "scores": {
    "wholeClip": true,
    "speechQualityScoreq": {
     "phone": 3.08,
     "diffio": 4.59,
     "clean": 4.57
    },
    "voiceSimilarityToClean": {
     "phone": 0.453,
     "diffio": 0.678
    },
    "voiceSimilarityPhoneBand": {
     "phone": 0.719,
     "diffio": 0.834
    },
    "wordErrorRate": {
     "phone": 0.0,
     "diffio": 0.0
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "slug": "weak-signal-amr",
   "testId": "vm24",
   "label": "made by passing a clean recording through real phone codecs (not a real voicemail)",
   "phoneChain": "phone band 300-3400 Hz at 8 kHz -> AMR-NB 5.9 kbps (opencore-amr 0.1.6) -> G.711 mu-law -> AMR-NB 12.2 kbps (voicemail store)",
   "deliveredAs": "the stored AMR-NB file itself (Android visual voicemail, call recorders)",
   "situation": "phone on a table 1-2 m away: synthetic room response RT60 0.57 s, DRR 1.0 dB, plus DLIVING noise at 25 dB SNR",
   "voice": {
    "speaker": "Algy Pug",
    "work": "Letters to Dead Authors, section 21 (To Omar Kha'yya'm)",
    "sourcePageUrl": "https://librivox.org/letters-to-dead-authors-by-andrew-lang/",
    "license": "public domain (LibriVox recording; LibriVox dedicates its recordings to the public domain)",
    "credit": "Algy Pug, LibriVox (librivox.org)"
   },
   "noise": "\"DEMAND: a collection of multi-channel recordings of acoustic noise in diverse environments\", Joachim Thiemann, Nobutaka Ito, Emmanuel Vincent (2013), https://zenodo.org/records/1227121, CC BY-SA 3.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/)",
   "license": "CC BY-SA 3.0 (adaptation of DEMAND noise)",
   "excerpt": {
    "startSeconds": 0.0,
    "durationSeconds": 21.78,
    "clipSeconds": 21.79
   },
   "files": {
    "phone": "weak-signal-amr-phone.mp3",
    "diffio": "weak-signal-amr-diffio.mp3",
    "clean": "weak-signal-amr-clean.mp3"
   },
   "scores": {
    "wholeClip": true,
    "speechQualityScoreq": {
     "phone": 1.61,
     "diffio": 4.91,
     "clean": 4.56
    },
    "voiceSimilarityToClean": {
     "phone": 0.368,
     "diffio": 0.595
    },
    "voiceSimilarityPhoneBand": {
     "phone": 0.524,
     "diffio": 0.815
    },
    "wordErrorRate": {
     "phone": 0.2807,
     "diffio": 0.0
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "slug": "car-noise",
   "testId": "vm10",
   "label": "made by passing a clean recording through real phone codecs (not a real voicemail)",
   "phoneChain": "phone band 300-3400 Hz at 8 kHz -> GSM 06.10 full rate (ffmpeg libgsm) -> G.711 mu-law",
   "deliveredAs": "AAC 32 kbps in M4A (the format an iPhone voicemail Share / Save to Files gives)",
   "situation": "car interior noise (TCAR) at 11.1 dB SNR in the phone band",
   "voice": {
    "speaker": "Jonathan Jones",
    "work": "Letters from Hell, section 1 (Letter I)",
    "sourcePageUrl": "https://librivox.org/letters-from-hell-by-valdemar-adolph-thisted/",
    "license": "public domain (LibriVox recording; LibriVox dedicates its recordings to the public domain)",
    "credit": "Jonathan Jones, LibriVox (librivox.org)"
   },
   "noise": "\"DEMAND: a collection of multi-channel recordings of acoustic noise in diverse environments\", Joachim Thiemann, Nobutaka Ito, Emmanuel Vincent (2013), https://zenodo.org/records/1227121, CC BY-SA 3.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/)",
   "license": "CC BY-SA 3.0 (adaptation of DEMAND noise)",
   "excerpt": {
    "startSeconds": 0.0,
    "durationSeconds": 23.3,
    "clipSeconds": 46.63
   },
   "files": {
    "phone": "car-noise-phone.mp3",
    "diffio": "car-noise-diffio.mp3",
    "clean": "car-noise-clean.mp3"
   },
   "scores": {
    "wholeClip": true,
    "speechQualityScoreq": {
     "phone": 1.91,
     "diffio": 4.85,
     "clean": 4.25
    },
    "voiceSimilarityToClean": {
     "phone": 0.566,
     "diffio": 0.701
    },
    "voiceSimilarityPhoneBand": {
     "phone": 0.664,
     "diffio": 0.826
    },
    "wordErrorRate": {
     "phone": 0.13,
     "diffio": 0.05
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "slug": "older-man",
   "testId": "vm01",
   "label": "made by passing a clean recording through real phone codecs (not a real voicemail)",
   "phoneChain": "phone band 300-3400 Hz at 8 kHz -> G.711 mu-law (ffmpeg pcm_mulaw)",
   "deliveredAs": "MP3 32 kbps of the 8 kHz call audio (Google Fi documents MP3 voicemail downloads; Google Voice MP3 is reported, not official)",
   "situation": "quiet room, phone held to the mouth",
   "voice": {
    "speaker": "Rafael Reyes (NPS oral history narrator)",
    "work": "Reyes, Rafael_Z35_WAPA-246_WAPA 4170_OralHist_Audio_public.mp3 (War in the Pacific NHP oral history)",
    "sourcePageUrl": "https://npgallery.nps.gov/AssetDetail/4a01732e-247e-4a24-8e3f-d42e877d8276",
    "license": "public domain (NPGallery: \"This digital asset is in the public domain\")",
    "credit": "Courtesy U.S. National Parks"
   },
   "noise": null,
   "license": "Public domain",
   "excerpt": {
    "startSeconds": 0.0,
    "durationSeconds": 25.75,
    "clipSeconds": 25.75
   },
   "files": {
    "phone": "older-man-phone.mp3",
    "diffio": "older-man-diffio.mp3",
    "clean": "older-man-clean.mp3"
   },
   "scores": {
    "wholeClip": true,
    "speechQualityScoreq": {
     "phone": 2.88,
     "diffio": 4.47,
     "clean": 3.5
    },
    "voiceSimilarityToClean": {
     "phone": 0.786,
     "diffio": 0.743
    },
    "voiceSimilarityPhoneBand": {
     "phone": 0.871,
     "diffio": 0.875
    },
    "wordErrorRate": {
     "phone": 0.0,
     "diffio": 0.0615
    }
   }
  },
  {
   "slug": "dropouts",
   "testId": "vm02",
   "label": "made by passing a clean recording through real phone codecs (not a real voicemail)",
   "phoneChain": "phone band 300-3400 Hz at 8 kHz -> G.711 mu-law (ffmpeg pcm_mulaw)",
   "deliveredAs": "AAC 32 kbps in M4A (the format an iPhone voicemail Share / Save to Files gives)",
   "situation": "quiet room, phone held to the mouth; burst frame loss 9.0 % of 20 ms frames (Gilbert-Elliott)",
   "voice": {
    "speaker": "elizabethhousworth",
    "work": "Letters on Different Subjects in Natural Philosophy, Volume 1 (Letters to a German Princess), section 75 (Changes Which May Take Place in the State of Bodies)",
    "sourcePageUrl": "https://librivox.org/letters-on-natural-philosophy-vol1-by-leonhard-euler",
    "license": "public domain (LibriVox recording; LibriVox dedicates its recordings to the public domain)",
    "credit": "elizabethhousworth, LibriVox (librivox.org)"
   },
   "noise": null,
   "license": "Public domain",
   "excerpt": {
    "startSeconds": 0.0,
    "durationSeconds": 25.9,
    "clipSeconds": 51.07
   },
   "files": {
    "phone": "dropouts-phone.mp3",
    "diffio": "dropouts-diffio.mp3",
    "clean": "dropouts-clean.mp3"
   },
   "scores": {
    "wholeClip": true,
    "speechQualityScoreq": {
     "phone": 2.11,
     "diffio": 4.31,
     "clean": 3.76
    },
    "voiceSimilarityToClean": {
     "phone": 0.814,
     "diffio": 0.655
    },
    "voiceSimilarityPhoneBand": {
     "phone": 0.897,
     "diffio": 0.841
    },
    "wordErrorRate": {
     "phone": 0.0177,
     "diffio": 0.0088
    }
   }
  }
 ],
 "realCall": {
  "id": "noaa-phone-a",
  "from": "diffio.ai speech enhancer test (/speech-enhancer-benchmark/)",
  "credit": "\"Diving Deeper: Exploring Hawaii's Coral Reefs\" (December 2015), NOAA Ocean Service podcast, public domain"
 }
}
